No, I don’t work for FTDNA, or get free stuff from the company, or have any stake in its success. My only connection is that I did my own autosomal (“Family Finder”) test with FTDNA, and convinced two of my male first cousins to Y-DNA test with the company. I have also encouraged other people to do the same.
I just want to say “good for you, FTDNA” about their ethical/privacy standards on a couple of issues. If you read this blog, you know I had a run-in with a family surname project administrator not long ago. I wrote about my experience on this blog and gave some advice about maintaining control of your FTDNA account. Several friends (project administrators) and I discussed the privacy/ethics issues involved, but we didn’t have hard and fast answers.
So I emailed the FTDNA help desk. I asked two questions:
(1) Is it ethical for a family surname project administrator to upgrade a participant’s test kit without first getting prior express written permission from the participant who tested?
(2) Is it ethical for a family surname project administrator to revise a test participant’s family tree without getting prior express written permission?
FTDNA’s prompt reply was “NO” and “NO.” Here is FTDNA’s reply verbatim:
“1) Before ordering testing on any account, you must have express written permission from the test taker where they agree to further testing.
2) You are not allowed to make changes to a members tree without their express written permission.”
There is nothing equivocal about that. No exceptions, no caveats. FTDNA did not say “except it is OK to change a member’s tree if you have the account password.” Ditto on ordering further testing — unequivocally verboten, even if you have the account password.
So thanks, FTDNA. I’m glad to hear it.