This article is about two men named Edward Lindsey. They’ve been conflated with each other because they purportedly share the unusual middle name Buxton. Talk about understandable confusion!
If you’ve landed on this website via a search on a “Lindsey” name, you may have already seen the post on Edward Buxton Lindsey (“EBL”), my great-great grandfather (link provided below). I did a lousy job in that article of proving that EBL was who I said he was. Specifically, I failed to prove that EBL of Nash County, NC lived in Barbour Co., AL after he left Nash, and then moved further west.
Fortunately, a nice lady who read the EBL article posted a comment which made me aware I had goofed. Here is her comment, edited a bit:
I am a direct descendant of Edward Buxton Lindsey myself, or so I thought. Have you found any information to back this lineage up?
According to my tree, and to many others on ancestry.com, my lineage is as follows: William Lindsey of Nash Co., NC (d. 1817) m. Mary (“Polly”) LNU. They were the parents of Edward Buxton Lindsey (1797-1872) who married as his first wife Rachel Murphy (1803-1830).
End of comment. Bad on me, and thanks to Jessica Richmond for her question. When someone asks, “have you found any information to back this lineage up,” you’ve obviously done a lousy job of proving your case. To make amends, I’m writing now to address this question:
Where did Edward Buxton Lindsey of Nash Co., NC, son of William Lindsey, go after his father died in 1817?
First, let’s talk about Jessica’s ancestor Edward Lindsey (1797-1872), who married as his first wife Rachel Murphy. He arrived in Benton Co., TN by at least 1836, and apparently lived there until he died. Since Benton was created in December 1835 from Henry and Humphrys counties, it is possible that Edward appears in the records of one of those counties before 1836. I haven’t looked in either county’s records, although the Edward Lindsey enumerated in Henry Co. in the 1830 federal census is probably the same man. Here are some Benton Co., TN records for Edward, all available at Ancestry.com and/or FamilySearch.org:
- 1836 Benton Co. , TN tax list, Edward Lindsey. John, William and James Lindsey were also shown on that tax list.
- 1837 Benton Co. tax list, Edward Lindsey, ditto.
- 1838 tax list, ditto.
- 1840 federal census, Benton Co., Edward Lyndsey, age 40-49.
- 1850 federal census, Benton Co., Edward Lindsey, 52, b. NC (with second wife Levisa, whose name has various spellings).
- 1860 federal census, Benton Co., Edward Linsy, 63, b. NC (wife Lavicy).
- 1870 federal census, Benton Co., E. Lindsey, 73, b. NC (wife Lavinia).
- Tombstone in the Edward Lindsey cemetery in Big Sandy, Benton Co., TN: “Edward Lindsey, b. 31 Jan 1797 d. 5 Mar 1872.” Here is the findagrave website with a photo of Edward’s tombstone. The findagrave site (but not the tombstone) shows Edward Lindsey with the middle initial “B.” And a monument erected by descendants also uses the middle initial “B.”
Benton County Edward was kind enough to stay in the same place for more than three decades. It’s a good bet that there is some record there containing a middle name or middle initial, if he ever used one. I haven’t found any. A descendant of his with whom I exchanged emails a number of years ago also found no record of him ever using a middle name or initial. That doesn’t prove Benton County Edward’s middle name wasn’t Buxton. It does cast some shade on the possibility.
OK, let’s shift our focus from Benton County Edward and go back to the Nash County, NC will of William Lindsey. Here is a link to a post containing a complete transcription of the 1817 will.
William left his widow Polly (a common nickname for Mary) a life estate in his home “plantation.” It was located in Nash County on Sapony/Sappony Creek. After Polly’s life estate expired (i.e., after she died), the land went to William’s son Edward Buxton Lindsey. The will used Edward’s full name.
EBL appeared in Nash County for several years after his father died. His older brother Asbury Lindsey became guardian of EBL and his siblings William Ray and Polly Mintz Lindsey in February 1819. The court recited Edward’s middle name in the guardian appointment. Subsequently, EBL’s brother John Wesley Lindsey became Edward’s guardian, posting the requisite annual guardian’s bond on Feb. 16, 1825. John Wesley also filed his annual accounting of EBL’s estate that month. The originals of both the bond and the accounting are available in the “Search Room” at the State Archives of North Carolina in Raleigh. The Search Room makes hundreds of thousands (perhaps millions?) of records available to the public in the form of both original records and microfilm.
Back to the point: in order to need a guardian, the ward must have been less than age 21 (or non compos mentis, which isn’t an issue here). Since EBL had a guardian in February 1825, he must have been born sometime after February 1804.
And there is the first problem with the theory that Benton County Edward was the same man as EBL of Nash County. Benton County Edward’s tombstone says that he was born in January 1797. He would have been 28 in 1825 and in no need of a guardian.
Meanwhile, my ancestor Edward B. Lindsey appeared in four consecutive federal censuses (1850 through 1880) as having been born in North Carolina about 1811 – 1812. He would have still been underage through at least 1831.
That’s not enough to prove that the Edward B. Lindsey in those census records was the same man as EBL, son of William Lindsey of Nash County. For proof of that, we need to look at additional Nash County records – and some records in Pike and Barbour County, AL.
EBL’s last appearance in Nash County in person was in March 1827 at the estate sale of his brother, William Ray Lindsey. Edward purchased a bedstead and linens, a pocket knife, a man’s saddle, a razor, an arithmetic book, a “cypering book,” and an ink stand. The last three items suggest that his brother and guardian John Wesley was seeing to Edward’s education, as William Lindsey’s 1817 will instructed. The purchases also prompt an image of a young man teetering on the brink of adulthood, in need of his own razor … but still engaged in schoolwork.
The 1830 census for Nash County does not have a listing for EBL, although his brothers Asbury and John Wesley both appear as heads of households. EBL was still around Nash, though, because the county court tried to find John Wesley in early 1832 in connection with his annual guardian’s bond and accounting. EBL’s guardian’s file contains the original of a summons dated February 2, 1832, ordering the sheriff to summon John W. Lindsey to appear at the May court to “show cause why he has not renewed his bond and returned his accounts as guardian to Edward B. Lindsey.” The order was dated Feb. 2 and issued April 10, 1832. On the reverse side of the summons it says this: “The Court vs. John W. Lindsey, gdn Edward B. Lindsey, May Term 1832. Not to be found in the County of Nash … the Deft [sic, defendant, i.e., John Wesley] has moved himself to the Mississippi.”
And that is the last record I have found in Nash County for John Wesley Lindsey. He and EBL clearly left Nash by early 1832, possibly together.
I found only one more Nash County record concerning EBL, a deed dated Nov. 21, 1836:
Charles Livingston of Barbor Co., Alabama (sic, Barbour) to Jeptha Lindsey of Nash, NC, 200 acres in Nash on the south side of Sappony Cr., “it being the lands left to Edward B. Lindsey by his father William Lindsey.”
Moving on to Alabama … there is a marriage record in Pike Co., AL for Edward B. Lindsey and Elizabeth J. Odom dated June 30, 1832. Barbour Co. was created in Dec. 1832 from the Creek Cession of 1812 and part of Pike County. There are a number of records for Edward B. Lindsey in Barbour County, including the state census of 1833. Here is the most important, because it proves that his full name was Edward Buxton Lindsey:
Deed dated Sept. 29, 1838 between Isaac Wilkins of Barbour Co. and E. Buxton Lindsey, also of Barbour Co., signed Edward B. Lindsey.
There is no listing for Edward in the 1840 census, although he and Elizabeth Jane were clearly still in Barbour County. In 1842, EBL and his wife of Barbour Co. sold four tracts in Barbour County to Hubbard S. Odom.
In short, a man named Edward Buxton Lindsey lived in Barbour County during at least 1833 through 1842. In 1836, a man who also lived in Barbour County sold Edward B. Lindsey’s tract on Sappony Creek in Nash County, NC, which Edward inherited from his father William.
I have not yet found a deed in which EBL conveyed his interest in his father’s Sappony Creek tract to Charles Livingston, but that would just be icing on the cake. If the other two deeds don’t convince you that EBL of Nash was the same man as EBL of Barbour Co., AL in 1838, then you’re a tough nut to crack. It’s good enough for me.
Also in 1838, Benton County Edward Lindsey appeared on the Benton County tax list, and he was still there in 1870. He was not the same man as Edward Buxton Lindsey of Nash and Barbour counties, who inherited his father’s tract on Sappony Creek.
EBL, son of William Lindsey of Nash, moved west from Barbour County. In 1845, his daughter Amanda Adieanna Lindsey was born in Mississippi. I don’t know where in Mississippi she was born, but I’m betting it was somewhere en route between Barbour Co. and Drew Co., AR. That is where EBL and his wife Elizabeth Jane Odom Lindsey were listed in the 1850 census, see footnote 4. Elizabeth Jane died in Drew County in October 1854 at age 42. Her obituary identifies her as the daughter of Jacob and Nancy Odom, “who emigrated to south Alabama.”
There is no reasonable doubt that Edward Buxton Lindsey and his wife Elizabeth Jane Odom Lindsey of Drew Co., AR were the same people as the couple by those names who previously lived in Barbour Co., AL.
Edward wasn’t lucky in marriage. Elizabeth Jane Odom, the first of four wives, died leaving 9 or 10 children. His second marriage to Ruth Crook in Drew County ended in divorce. In Claiborne Parish, LA (where his daughter Amanda Lindsey Rankin and his son William Lindsey both lived), he married wife number three, Elizabeth J. Marshall. She died in Tyler Co., TX, leaving Edward with an infant son. Marriage number four to Permelia Dean in Tyler County also ended in divorce. Edward returned to Claiborne Parish, where he last appeared in the 1880 census with his 10-year old son, Edward Lindsey Jr.
Edward’s story of four marriages, and his daughter Amanda Rankin’s story of love at first sight, are my two favorite oral family legends. You can find Edward’s legend and Amanda’s legend in articles on this website.
One last comment, stated as gently and kindly as I possibly can. Family trees posted at Ancestry.com don’t prove anything, even if there are dozens of them saying the same thing. Mostly, they prove how easy it is to import other peoples’ trees. Family trees posted at wikitree, FamilySearch.org, findagrave websites, surname DNA projects, and other websites have the same failing. If you find a tree with an unproved possible ancestor on it, contact the author and ask nicely for relevant evidence. I’ve met a bunch of nice people (and good researchers) that way!
See you on down the road … I’m heading (figuratively speaking) for Virginia and Pennsylvania on the trail of some Rankins.
* * * * * * * * * * *
 Timothy W. Rackley, Nash County North Carolina Court Minutes Volume IX 1818 – 1821 (Kernersville, NC: 1996), abstract of p. 235, entry of 8 Feb 1819 appointing Asberry (sic) Lindsey guardian of William Ray Lindsey, Polly Mintz Lindsey, and Edward Buxton Lindsey, orphans of William Lindsey, dec’d.
 The first banner at the Archives’ website has a picture of the search room showing its red upholstered chairs and a woman searching through one of the fibreboard boxes containing original records. https://archives.ncdcr.gov
 State Archives of North Carolina, fibreboard box designated C.R.069.510.7, “Nash County Guardians Records Horn, Henry – McDade, Drucilla 1784 – 1874,” file folder labeled “Lindsey, Edward B. 1832.”
 1850 federal census, Drew Co., AR, E. B. Lindsey, 39 (born about 1811), b. NC, with Elizabeth J. Lindsey (wife #1), 28, and 8 children; 1860 federal census, Drew Co., AR, E. B. Lindsey, 48 (born about 1812), b. NC with Ruth Lindsey (wife #2) and 4 children (the Lindsey children are missing in that census); 1870 federal census, Tyler Co., TX, Edw. Lindsey, 59 (born about 1811), b. NC, with wife Eliz. Lindsey (wife #3) and 1 child; 1880 federal census, Claiborne Parish, LA, Edward B. Lindsey, 69 (born about 1811), b. NC, with a son, Edward B. Lindsey, 11, born in Texas.
 State Archives of North Carolina, fibreboard box designated CR.069.508.47, Nash Estate Records, file folder labeled “Wm. Ray Lindsey 1827.”
 1830 federal census, Nash Co., NC, p. 186, household of Asberry Lindsey; p. 188, household of John W. Lindsey.
 State Archives of North Carolina, fibreboard box designated C.R.069.510.7, “Nash County Guardians Records Horn, Henry – McDade, Drucilla 1784 – 1874,” file folder labeled “Lindsey, Edward B. 1832.”
 State Archives of North Carolina, Film Box No. C.069.40006, microfilm of Nash Co. Deed Book 16: 206.
 Family Adventures, Early Alabama Marriages 1813 – 1850, (San Antonio: 1991), marriage record for Edward B. Lindsey and Elizabeth J. Odom, 30 Jun 1832, Pike Co., AL.
 Alabama Department of Archives and History, microfilm of Barbour County Deed Book F: 54; see also FamilySearch.org Film No. 7,897,788, digitized images of Barbour Co., AL Deed Book Volumes E-G 1842-1846, at Deed Book F: 54.
 Alabama Department of Archives and History, microfilm of Barbour County Deed Book E: 114. Hubbard Stubbs Odom was Elizabeth Jane Odom Lindsey’s brother. For some reason that is beyond me, EBL bought those same four tracts back from Hubbard in 1843. Microfilm of Barbour County Deed Book F: 45.
 E. M. Tipton, Marriages and Obituaries from the New Orleans Christian Advocate 1851-1860, Vol. 1 (Bossier City, LA: Tipton Printing & Publishing,1980). Elizabeth Jane Odom Lindsey’s obit appeared in the New Orleans Christian Advocate issue of 25 Nov. 1854, No. 3, Page 3, Col. 1.
 Jennie Belle Lyle, Marriage Record Book B, Drew Co., Arkansas (Little Rock: Democrat Printing & Lithography Co., 1966), marriage record for E. B. Lindsey and Ruth B. Crook, 16 Sep 1856; Willie Huffman Farley, Claiborne Parish, Louisiana Marriage Records, 1849-1940 (Shreveport: J & W Enterprises, 1984), marriage of E. B. Lendsey and E. J. Marshall, 15 Nov 1865; and Frances T. Ingmire, Marriage Records of Tyler County, Texas 1847 – 1888 (St. Louis: 1981), marriage of Ed. B. Lindsey and Permelia Dean, 20 Nov 1872.
6 thoughts on ““Same Name Confusion:” Edward Buxton Lindsey(s)”
Robin, my ears perk up when I learn that Edward B. Lindsey married Elizabeth Jane Odom, and that her obituary says her parents were Jacob and Nancy Odom. I don’t think I had known about these continuing Lindsey-Odom connections as these families moved west out of Nash County. At least, this is one I hadn’t known about.
To refresh your memory: I suspect that a Theophilus Odom who died in Nash County before 13 November 1811 is my ancestor, and that he was father of my ancestor Alcie Odom, who married Wilson Batchelor, son of Samuel Batchelor of Nash County. The 13 November 1811 date is the date on which Theophilus’ widow Dinah Odom relinquished administration of Theophilus’ estate to William Lindsey.
There are a lot of “supposes” in this Odom family tree, and I am far from sure I have worked it out correctly. I have concluded — but tentatively — that Dinah may have married John Lindsey prior to Theophilus Odom, and that John died in Nash County about 1781. I also think that John may have had brothers Joseph and William, and I think your William is the William who died in 1817 in Nash County — but I may be wrong about that, and if so, please tell me.
I think Theophilus and Dinah Odom had children Alcie, Abraham, and Jacob. Jacob seems to have been born 1784-1794 and married Christian, daughter of Nathan Vick, bef. 23 April 1810 in Nash County. Jacob died testate in Nash County between 2 Sept. 1841 (the date of his will) and Nov. 1841, when the will was probated. He had a son Jacob. I haven’t been able to track the children of Jacob and Christian Vick Odom with any certainty. I’m not wondering if the son Jacob named in the will of the Jacob who died in 1841 is the father of Elizabeth Jane Odom?
Bill, I agree that John Lindsey had a wife Diana (possibly Dinah). I can’t prove his children, if any. John did have brothers named Joseph (showed up in Franklin Co., and his children can be established with a fair degree of confidence) and William. ONE of the two — John or William — was undoubtedly (according to DNA Group 3) the father of William Lindsey d. 1817.
I’ve never been able to prove any connection between my Nash Lindseys and the Nash Odoms. Elizabeth Jane Odom Lindsey, wife of Edward Buxton and daughter of Jacob and Nancy Stubbs Odom, was born in Georgia. Before Georgia, her Odom family (and her Hubbard and Stubbs families) lived in Marlboro Co., SC. I believe Jacob Odom’s father was a John Odom who died in Marlboro either shortly before or shortly after 1800. I haven’t been able to get them back any further than that. These Odoms reused the same names ad nauseam, ad infinitum — they were partial to Old Testament characters. Aaron, Jacob, Isaac, Abraham. Also John (can’t ever leave out the writer of all those epistles!) and William. There was a John Odom in Nash County who owned land on the same Creek as the Lindsey patriarch of Edgecombe/Fairfax/Nash, and that’s the only connection I can find there. Perhaps we need to check out the Odom YDNA project!
Robin, thank you. Yes, you’ve put your finger on the problem — the replication of names ad nauseam in Odom families that are, I’m pretty sure, all part of one big set of Odoms, who fanned out early on from their roots in Nansemond Co., VA, and Chowan Co., NC, into old Edgecombe Co., NC, and from there to places like Marlboro Co., SC. This is exactly why I have never been able to sure I’ve sorted these lines with anything approaching minimal accuracy: the proliferation of Abrahams and Jacobs, etc.
I’m pretty sure that the Odoms in Nash Co., NC, were connected to the ones in Marlboro Co., SC, and that both lines stem from the Richard Odom who died testate in Chowan in 1728 with sons Richard, John, Abraham, Jacob, and Aaron and daughters Ann, Sarah, Elizabeth, and Jane, with wife Jane. But how they descend from that Richard, I have never been able to prove because of the maddening replication of given names. I also think Richard was in Nansemond before he moved to Chowan.
Hi William, I am a direct descendant of Richard Odum of Chowan, NC through Abraham Odom Sr, Abraham Odom Jr, Jacob Odom, and ultimately John Odum, b. 1776 in Marlboro, SC, d. 1861 in Columbus, GA. I have taken quite a few dna tests including a Y111 and BigY test through familytreedna.com. This haplogroup for our line of Odoms is I1-M253 > I-Z138 > S5619. I’d be happy to share any Odom family info / records I have with you, if interested.
Dave, perhaps we could get a three-way email conversation going with William (Bill) Lindsey? I trace my Odom line from the Marlboro Co. Odoms as well (Abraham/John/Jacob m. Nancy Stubbs). I have not looked at the Odoms in a while, but haven’t proved the line back to Chowan. I will forward your message to William, as I am not confident that he will receive it through the WordPress system. Thanks for the comment!
Robin, that would be great, thank you! The Odoms really are a confusing bunch. Multiple unrelated genetic lines often claiming the same ancestors, plus multiple name spellings or mispellings to further confuse the issue : )